List

Yadav (2010) and MacInnis (2011), both highlight that fact that empirical advances have outpaced the increased research on conceptualizations that enhance marketing thought. There is a decline in conceptual papers and this is a detrimental trend for our field’s growth because conceptual articles not only provide new ideas but also are more influential (in terms of citations and awards) than empirical papers (Yadav 2010).  He also points out that conceptual papers play an important role in maintaining the discovery-justification balance in a field of research. According to MacInnis (2011), conceptualization is a process of abstract thinking involving the mental representation of an idea. Conceptual thinking is the process of understanding a situation or problem abstractly by identifying patterns or connections. Conceptual articles are academic articles devoted purely to thought-based conceptions (no data), for example, conceptual frameworks, integrative models, and  reviews. These types of contributions are important for a field’s advancement because:

 

1.)   These articles contribute toward development of new constructs that are basic units of knowledge advancement. Without understanding our concepts and constructs we cannot think in the right direction. If the conceptual papers do not conceptualize new constructs, we would keep studying the same constructs and limit our views about the world. Also, constructs are the fundamental basis on which measures are derived and theories are constructed and tested. Thus, their development is important.

 

2.)   Reaching out (Wells 1993) is also for paramount significance to advance a research stream and also in the context of discovery. Conceptual advancement at the level of domains and cross-functional research through conceptual articles is critical to marketing academics and practice because it enhances the vitality of the field by introducing us to new unexplored areas, concepts and theories.

 

3.)   Conceptual advances can also take place at procedural levels where there can be thought exchange about new methods, indentifying new procedures, implementation issues, challenges and limitations of a method/procedure, and novel ideas on how to solve those issues.

 

4.)   A field can also grow by identifying and explaining relationships between constructs in a nomological network. When we understand these relationships, theories can be constructed, and these in turn clarify our knowledge about the world. Theories can also enable managers to have some predictive power of phenomena around them. Thus, conceptual understanding from theories enhances and refines our perspectives of the world and also avoids saturation in knowledge development. It is not just important to keep testing existing theories but it is equally important to develop new theories and thought processes that advance a field’s knowledge base.

 

But despite so many advantages of conceptual contributions, there are challenges it has to face, as identified by Yadav (2010): (1) Scholars’ ability and interest in integrative conceptual work has diminished, (2) doctoral programs concentrate heavily on method and analytical tools rather than on conceptual development seminars, (3) even the promotion and tenure system needs to give importance to conceptual contributions, and (4) the same applies to reviewers and review process too that give a disproportionate importance to empirical work and methodological rigor as compared to new ideas, theories or conceptual work.

 

Ultimately, I would say that conceptual papers should also be of high quality in terms of conceptual clarity, rationale, theoretical precision, scope, empirical testability of the model in the future, well-explained and drafted, logical thought flow, and logical managerial implications.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  Posts

March 27th, 2017

Why do Firms Delete Brands?

General Motors deleted Hummer, Oldsmobile, Saturn, and Pontiac in the last decade. Unilever trimmed its brand portfolio from 1,600 to […]

July 13th, 2012

Panel Discussion – An Active Learning Tool

In the real business environment, activities are not conducted in water-tight compartments. Different business functions are interdependent and interact with each other on a regular basis. But students in a marketing classroom (without any prior work experience) would neither know much about cross functionality nor would they understand the importance of working together with other functions. Thus, a cross-functional integration in the marketing curriculum would enable students to have a broader perspective about business issues and activities and would convey the mutually dependent roles in business decision making.

July 13th, 2012

Blog – A Technology for Active Learning

The blog area on the Blackboard site of various courses is rarely used for teaching and learning. The blog has a great potential to initiate discussion, exchange knowledge and information in a fun way, communicate one’s views and opinions, network, and build relationships. Even if a university is not using Blackboard, the Professor can still have a blog on the course website.

July 12th, 2012

Enhancing Marketing Thought…

Empirical advances have outpaced the increased research on conceptualizations that enhance marketing thought. There is a decline in conceptual papers and this is a detrimental trend for our field’s growth because conceptual articles not only provide new ideas but also are more influential (in terms of citations and awards) than empirical papers.

July 12th, 2012

Pink and Blue…

The term stereotype derives from the Greek words στερεός (stereos), “firm, solid” and τύπος (typos), “impression,” hence “solid impression”. Since we have been infants, we have seen stereotyping all around us and interestingly it has been influencing us since then.

June 26th, 2012

Be Yourself!

Try to be yourself! This is the most common advice we receive from our friends, family, teachers, and well wishers. But unless you understand and accept yourself first, you cannot be yourself. It is of utmost importance for you to identify the real you and be true to your self. Then, people around you will start seeing you in that light and accept you, understand you, and love you the way you are.

June 21st, 2012

Think!

So, what are thoughts? Why do we think?

Thinking starts when we face a problem and ends when we have a solution for the problem. They say that thinking is the highest human mental activity which is also the reason behind all human accomplishments and progress. This is because thought precedes action. Anything before being actually done, is first imagined in the human mind. Thus, action and thought are inseparable. As Einstein very emphatically puts it,

The whole of Science is nothing more than a refinement of everyday thinking.

June 21st, 2012

My Experience With Life In The United States Of America

Our first two learning sources are our parents and teachers. True! But our best teacher is experience and what we learn from the world contradicts most of what we learned from the first two teachers. When this thought ran across my mind, I decided to write about my life in the USA. So, here I am, seated in a small coffee shop of a small town in the US pouring my thoughts on paper.